Former Boston Braves slugger Tommy Holmes has passed away. I won’t B.S. you guys and pretend this is especially sad news, because, in case you didn’t notice, I said he played for the Boston freaking Braves! If I’d said he played for the Milwaukee Braves that might be a little sad, and if I said he played for the Atlanta Braves you might even cry, but a Boston Brave? That’d be like a Today Show viewer being depressed that someone Willard Scott wished a Happy Birthday to had passed away.
You know why else you shouldn’t be sad? Tommy checked out in the old timer’s paradise of Boca Raton, Florida, at the ripe old age of 91. Ninety-one! Tommy clearly got the chance to eat a LOT of early bird specials and to complain about a LOT of those damn kids today. Still, something strikes me as sad about saying farewell to Tommy, which is especially weird because, as someone yet to cash a social security check, I never got the chance to see him play.
So what is making me sad? Well, part of it has to do with the fact that a player as accomplished as Tommy was largely forgotten by baseball at the time of his death. The native of Brooklyn did some truly amazing things on the field, a good number of which happened in his landmark 1945 season when he made the All-Star team, finished second in the MVP voting, and managed to get a hit in 37 consecutive games (a record that stood for 33 years until Pete Rose broke it). As if that wasn’t enough, Tommy finished the year with a .352 average and became the first and only player to lead his league in both home runs and fewest strike outs per at bat (How few? Try 9 punch-outs in 636 at bats!).
Okay…so maybe some of his amazing stats that year were inflated because a baker’s dozen or so great pitchers were overseas serving during WW II, and, oh yeah, the league was made up of nothing but pasty skinned honkies, but in Tommy’s defense he continued to perform at a very high level once the war ended and the color barrier was broke. In 1948, for example, he was an All-Star who hit .325, lead the league in outfield put-outs for the fifth consecutive year (yeah, he could field too), and took his team to the World Series.
So how come so many baseball fans haven’t heard of him? The answer is because he only amassed 75 at bats after the age of 33, a fact which resulted in his finishing with a far from HOF worthy 1,502 hits despite a career .302 average. Why you may ask? Well, it seems that, like sixteen-year-old girl on Tyra obsessed with becoming a Mom, Tommy wanted to become a manager way before his time at the age of 33 (following a season when he hit a still very good .298). So, in 1951, Tommy suited up as the Braves’ player/manager (hmmm…you think Pete Rose studied up on Tommy after breaking his record?). Unfortunately, he was fired by the team he had done so much for after only a far from disastrous season and a half. Tommy, with his tenure as the Braves’ skipper ended so prematurely, then decided to pick up his bat and return to playing. He signed with the Dodgers, but, after being used primarily as a pinch hitter, hit only .111 in thirty six at bats before retiring at the still young age of 35. Did the Braves ask him back to play? Manage? Clean the toilets? The answer is no, no, and thankfully, no.
Now I’ll be the first to admit I don’t know the specifics of this bizarre-ass story, and the internet and battalion of baseball books on my shelf have done little to clear things up (note: if anyone out there can fill me in on the details I would greatly appreciate it and post it here). Nevertheless, it seems to me like yet another example of how an old time ball player was jerked around by his fat cat owner (who I always imagine as obscenely obese, wearing a three piece suit, and smoking a cigar while cleaning his monocle). This is sad because, while today a lousy back-up infielder makes over a million dollars a year, All-Stars of the black and white era were forced to work at gas stations in the off season. There was very little allegiance to players by their team back then, something anyone who has seen John Sayles’ wonderful film Eight Men Out knows. Sox hurler Eddie Cicotte was benched by owner Charles Comiskey toward the end of the 1919 season because Comiskey didn’t want him to realize a ten grand incentive for winning thirty games. Eddie finished that year with 29 wins, a measly six thousand dollars in salary, and was coerced to join the seven other cheaters who turned the 1919 White Sox black. Even a player as great as Babe Ruth was screwed with. The Babe, after being denied the chance to manage the Yanks (who should have polished each and every one of his hot dog and booze induced turds until the day he died), was traded to Tommy’s team, the Boston Braves, with the promise of possibly managing in 1936. Sadly, the Braves were making false promises (In heaven Tommy yells down, “No, crap, blogger!”), and the closest the Babe ever came to realizing his dream of managing before passing away was coaching the Dodgers for half a season.
Anyway, I will acknowledge that there may be another explanation for the early end to Tommy’s career, but it certainly wasn’t attitude (he was known to be a great guy) or interest in the game (he scouted for many years with the Mets). I suppose he may have been injured somewhat, but if he was I’d imagine he would have simply managed and not played as well – especially not after being fired as manager. I’m sorry to say it seems Tommy was yet another victim of the time period he played in.
So, the next time a modern day owner leverages his team in order to get some a-hole like Miguel Tejada who then giggles and says, “Guess what, suckas? I’m actually forty-seven!” remember our heroes weren’t always treated like little Medici princes. Actually, now that I think about it, it isn’t us fans who should remember this but today’s players. They need to know that “baseball been berry, berry good” to them, and that it hasn’t always been that way. So, Miguel Tejada and the other 847 of you, the next time a kid asks you for an autograph or your manager asks you to take a few extra ground balls, you better damn well better do it. Otherwise I just might show up with a twelve pack of over sized eggs and hurl them at your Humvee in honor of Eddie Cicotte, The Babe, and the late, great Tommy Holmes.
Tags:
Braves,
Dodgers